Perspectives of Women Rights in Islam
(880)
Q.1 Write notes on the following.
i.
CEDAW
i.
CEDAW (Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against
Women):
CEDAW is an international treaty adopted by the
United Nations General Assembly in 1979. It is often referred to as the
international bill of rights for women. The convention aims to eliminate
discrimination against women in all areas of life and promote gender equality.
Dear Student,
Ye sample assignment h. Ye bilkul
copy paste h jo dusre student k pass b available h. Agr ap ne university
assignment send krni h to UNIQUE assignment
hasil krne k lye ham c contact kren:
0313-6483019
0334-6483019
0343-6244948
University c related har news c
update rehne k lye hamra channel subscribe kren:
Key
points about CEDAW:
1.
Objectives: The primary
objective of CEDAW is to ensure that women enjoy equal rights with men in
political, economic, social, cultural, and civil spheres. It seeks to eliminate
all forms of discrimination against women and guarantee their fundamental human
rights and freedoms.
2.
Scope: CEDAW covers a wide range of
issues affecting women's lives, including access to education, healthcare,
employment, participation in decision-making processes, legal rights, marriage,
and family life.
3.
Non-discrimination: CEDAW establishes
the principle of non-discrimination, stating that women should not be treated
less favorably than men. It calls for the modification and elimination of
discriminatory laws, policies, and practices that perpetuate gender inequality.
4.
State obligations: States that have
ratified CEDAW are legally bound to implement its provisions and take measures
to eliminate gender-based discrimination. They are required to submit periodic
reports to the CEDAW Committee, an expert body that monitors the implementation
of the convention.
5.
Optional Protocol: The Optional
Protocol to CEDAW, adopted in 1999, allows individuals or groups to bring
complaints of violations of their rights under CEDAW to the attention of the
CEDAW Committee. It also enables the Committee to conduct inquiries into grave
or systematic violations of women's rights.
6.
Achievements: CEDAW has played a
significant role in promoting gender equality worldwide. It has influenced
national legislation, policies, and practices, leading to improvements in
women's rights and empowerment. Many countries have enacted laws and
established institutions to advance gender equality as a result of CEDAW.
7.
Challenges: Despite its impact,
challenges persist in fully realizing CEDAW's objectives. Some countries have
reservations or make limited interpretations of certain provisions, hindering
comprehensive implementation. In addition, deep-rooted gender stereotypes,
cultural norms, and unequal power structures pose obstacles to achieving gender
equality.
CEDAW has served as a crucial instrument in
advancing women's rights globally. It has contributed to raising awareness,
shaping policies, and holding governments accountable for gender equality.
However, ongoing efforts are necessary to overcome the remaining barriers and
ensure the full realization of women's rights and gender equality.
ii. Khutba Hujatul Wida:
The
Khutba Hujatul Wida, also known as the Farewell Sermon, is a historic sermon
delivered by Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) during his final pilgrimage
to Mecca in the year 632 CE. It is considered one of the most important
speeches in Islamic history and contains profound guidance for Muslims in
various aspects of life.
Key points about Khutba Hujatul Wida:
1. Location and Occasion: The
sermon was delivered at Mount Arafat, a significant location during the Hajj
pilgrimage. It was attended by a large gathering of Muslims from different
regions, making it a momentous event.
2. Universal Message: The
sermon encompasses universal teachings that are applicable to Muslims
throughout time and across different cultures and societies. It addresses
fundamental principles of Islam and provides guidance on matters of faith,
morality, social interaction, and human rights.
3. Equality and Brotherhood:
Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) emphasized the equality and brotherhood of all Muslims.
He stressed that no person is superior to another based on race, ethnicity, or
social status. The only criterion for distinction is righteousness and piety.
4. Sanctity of Life and Property: The
sermon emphasized the sacredness of human life and property. Prophet Muhammad
(pbuh) reiterated the importance of upholding the rights and dignity of every
individual. He explicitly stated that taking the life or property of a Muslim
is forbidden.
5. Women's Rights: The
sermon emphasized the rights and respect due to women in society. Prophet
Muhammad (pbuh) highlighted the importance of treating women with kindness,
fairness, and compassion. He addressed issues such as dowry, consent in
marriage, and the prohibition of mistreatment or oppression.
6. Social Justice: The
Khutba Hujatul Wida emphasized the significance of social justice and the
elimination of exploitation and oppression. Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) highlighted
the rights of laborers, fair treatment of creditors and debtors, and the
prohibition of usury (interest).
7. Finality of Prophethood: In
the sermon, Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) declared the completion of his prophethood
and emphasized that there would be no new prophet or divine revelation after
him. He affirmed that Islam is the final and complete religion for humanity.
The
Khutba Hujatul Wida serves as a comprehensive guide for Muslims, encompassing
essential principles of faith, morality, and social conduct. It highlights the
values of equality, justice, compassion, and respect for human rights. Muslims
around the world reflect on this sermon and strive to implement its teachings
in their personal lives and interactions with others. The Farewell Sermon
remains a cherished source of guidance and inspiration for Muslims, emphasizing
the Prophet's profound wisdom and his mission to establish a just and righteous
society.
Q.2 Write about
the following rights given by Islam to women:
i.
Marriage
i.
Marriage Rights Given by Islam to Women:
Islam grants several rights to women when it comes
to the institution of marriage. These rights are aimed at ensuring equality,
respect, and protection for women within the marital relationship. Here are
some key marriage rights given to women in Islam:
1.
Consent: Islam emphasizes the importance
of a woman's consent in marriage. It is a fundamental right for a woman to
willingly accept or reject a marriage proposal. Forced marriages or marriages
without the woman's consent are strongly discouraged and considered invalid in
Islamic teachings.
2.
Mahr (Dowry): The concept of mahr
is an essential aspect of Islamic marriage. It refers to a gift or financial
provision given by the husband to the wife as a symbol of love, commitment, and
financial security. The mahr belongs solely to the wife, and she has the right
to decide how to utilize it.
3.
Right to Maintenance: Islam places the
responsibility on the husband to provide for the financial maintenance and
support of his wife. This includes providing for her basic needs, such as food,
clothing, shelter, and medical care, as well as meeting her reasonable
lifestyle expectations.
4.
Right to Education and Employment:
Islam upholds a woman's right to education and personal development. Women are
encouraged to seek knowledge, pursue education, and develop skills. They also
have the right to engage in lawful employment or business ventures, if they
wish to do so, while maintaining their marital and familial responsibilities.
5.
Right to Physical and Emotional Well-being: Islam places great emphasis on the importance of mutual love, care, and
respect within a marital relationship. Husbands are instructed to treat their
wives with kindness, compassion, and equity. Any form of physical or emotional
abuse is strictly prohibited.
6.
Right to Divorce: Islam recognizes
that sometimes marriages may face irreconcilable issues. In such cases, both
men and women have the right to seek divorce, although the process may differ.
Women have the right to initiate divorce through means such as khula (where the
wife seeks divorce by returning the mahr) or talaq-e-tafweez (delegated
divorce), and they have the right to include divorce conditions in the marriage
contract.
7.
Custody and Guardianship: In matters of
custody and guardianship of children, Islam recognizes the natural maternal
bond and acknowledges a woman's nurturing abilities. In cases of divorce or the
death of the husband, women may be granted custody of their children until a
certain age or until certain conditions are met.
It is important to note that the implementation of
these rights may vary across different cultural and societal contexts. However,
the fundamental principles of equality, respect, and protection for women in
marriage remain consistent in Islamic teachings. These rights aim to ensure the
well-being, autonomy, and dignity of women within the institution of marriage,
promoting a harmonious and balanced relationship between spouses.
ii.
Khula/Dissolution
ii.
Khula/Dissolution Rights Given by Islam to Women:
In Islamic law, khula refers to a form of marital
dissolution initiated by the wife. It allows a woman to seek a divorce from her
husband through a mutual agreement or by offering compensation. Islam grants
women the right to khula as a means of seeking separation from an incompatible
or unhappy marriage. Here are some key points regarding the khula right given
to women in Islam:
1.
Women's Initiative: Khula recognizes and
respects a woman's autonomy and agency within the marriage. It acknowledges
that women may have valid reasons for seeking a divorce, and they have the
right to take the initiative in ending the marital relationship.
2.
Dissolution by Mutual Agreement: Khula
involves a voluntary agreement between the husband and wife to dissolve the
marriage. If both parties agree to separate, the woman can seek a khula by
returning the mahr (dowry) or offering financial compensation to the husband as
agreed upon.
3.
Seeking Dissolution through a Court: If
the husband refuses to grant khula, or if the couple cannot reach an agreement,
the woman can seek a dissolution through a court. The court evaluates the
situation and determines whether a valid reason for separation exists, such as
irreconcilable differences, neglect, abuse, or persistent harm.
4.
Financial Considerations: When seeking
khula, a woman may need to return the mahr or offer compensation to the husband
as agreed upon or determined by the court. This ensures that the husband is not
unjustly deprived of his rights and that the woman can seek separation fairly.
5.
Fair Settlement and Custody: In
the process of khula, the court may consider matters such as alimony, financial
support, and custody arrangements for children. The aim is to ensure a fair and
just settlement that takes into account the well-being of both parties, as well
as the welfare of any children involved.
6.
Women's Empowerment and Protection:
Khula provides women with an avenue to seek dissolution from an unhappy or
problematic marriage. It empowers them to make decisions about their own lives
and protects them from being trapped in a marriage that causes them harm or
distress.
7.
Spiritual and Emotional Well-being:
Islam recognizes that a harmonious and peaceful marriage is ideal. However, in
cases where reconciliation is not possible, khula allows women to prioritize
their spiritual and emotional well-being, fostering an environment of mutual
respect and reducing the potential for ongoing conflict.
It is important to note that the exact procedures
and conditions for khula may vary across different Islamic legal systems and
cultural contexts. However, the fundamental principle is to provide women with
a legitimate and equitable means of seeking dissolution from a marriage that is
incompatible or detrimental to their overall well-being. The objective is to
ensure that women are not trapped in unhappy or abusive relationships and have
the freedom to pursue a more fulfilling life.
iii.
Inheritance
iii.
Inheritance Rights Given by Islam to Women:
Islam recognizes the right of women to inherit
property and wealth. Inheritance laws in Islam aim to ensure fairness, justice,
and economic stability within families and society as a whole. Here are key
points regarding inheritance rights given to women in Islam:
1.
Quranic Basis: Inheritance rights
are derived from the Quran, particularly from Surah An-Nisa (Chapter 4), which
provides detailed guidelines on inheritance. Islam considers inheritance as a
matter of divine decree and emphasizes the importance of fair distribution.
2.
Equal Spiritual Worth: Islam affirms
the equal spiritual worth of men and women. While there are some differences in
inheritance laws based on gender, they are designed to maintain harmony and
consider various familial responsibilities.
3.
Fixed Shares: The Quran prescribes
fixed shares for different heirs based on their relationship to the deceased.
In general, daughters receive half the share of sons, while wives are entitled
to a specified portion depending on the presence of other relatives. These
proportions are designed to account for women's financial security and their
potential responsibilities as wives and mothers.
4.
Exclusive Inheritance: Women have the
right to inherit property and wealth from their deceased relatives, including
parents, spouses, children, and siblings. Their inheritance is independent and
separate from their marital status or financial circumstances.
5.
Ownership and Control: Women have full
ownership and control over the property they inherit. They can use, invest, or
dispose of their inherited assets as they deem fit. Islam encourages women to
exercise financial independence and make wise decisions regarding their wealth.
6.
Protection and Economic Security: Inheritance
rights provide women with a measure of economic security, ensuring that they
have assets and resources to support themselves and their families. This
empowers women to participate in economic activities and contribute to the
well-being of their households.
7.
Testamentary Dispositions: Islam allows
individuals to make testamentary dispositions (wills) within certain limits.
This provides additional flexibility for individuals, including women, to
allocate their wealth beyond the prescribed shares of inheritance, subject to
Islamic legal guidelines.
It is important to note that the specific
application of inheritance laws may vary across different cultural and legal
contexts within the broader Islamic framework. In some cases, cultural
practices and local customs may influence the implementation of inheritance
laws. However, the fundamental principle of providing women with inheritance
rights is a key aspect of Islamic teachings, aiming to ensure economic justice,
stability, and the well-being of women and their families.
iv. Evidence
iv. Evidence Rights Given by Islam to
Women:
In
Islamic law, women are granted the right to provide evidence and testify in
legal matters. Islam recognizes the testimonies of women as valid and
significant in legal proceedings. Here are key points regarding evidence rights
given to women in Islam:
1. Equality before the Law: Islam
emphasizes the principle of equality before the law, regardless of gender. Both
men and women are considered equal in terms of their rights and
responsibilities within the legal system.
2. Capacity to Provide Testimony: Women
possess the ability to provide evidence and testify in legal matters, including
civil, criminal, and family cases. Their testimonies carry weight and can
influence the outcome of a case.
3. Witnessing and Expertise: Women
can act as witnesses and provide testimony based on their personal knowledge
and expertise in specific fields. Their testimonies can cover a wide range of
matters, including financial transactions, contracts, family disputes, and
criminal offenses.
4. Conditions for Witnessing: Islamic
law establishes certain conditions for witnessing and providing testimony.
These conditions primarily focus on the integrity, competence, and reliability
of the witness, rather than their gender. A person's testimony is evaluated
based on their credibility, honesty, and knowledge of the facts.
5. Exceptions in Certain Cases: In
specific cases such as accusations of adultery (zina), witnesses are required
to be of good character and have seen the act directly. This is to ensure the
seriousness of such allegations and to prevent false accusations. However, it
is important to note that the burden of proof in cases of adultery is high and
requires multiple witnesses regardless of gender.
6. Supportive Evidence: Islamic
law recognizes that evidence can come in different forms, including
testimonies, documents, circumstantial evidence, and expert opinions. Women's
testimonies can be supported by other forms of evidence to establish the facts
of a case.
7. Role of Judges: It is
the responsibility of judges in Islamic legal systems to assess testimonies and
evidence objectively, regardless of the gender of the witness. Their role is to
evaluate the credibility, consistency, and reliability of the evidence
presented in order to ensure justice and fairness in the legal process.
It is
important to recognize that the interpretation and application of evidence
rights in Islamic legal systems can vary in different contexts and
jurisdictions. While Islam grants women the right to provide testimony,
cultural and societal practices may influence the actual implementation of
these rights. However, the underlying principle in Islam is to ensure equality,
fairness, and justice in legal proceedings, allowing women to have their voices
heard and their testimonies considered in legal matters.
Q.3 Differentiate
between the Complete Legal Capacity, Deficient Legal Capacity and Imperfect
Legal Capacity in Islamic law.
In
Islamic law, there are three categories that define the legal capacity of
individuals: Complete Legal Capacity, Deficient Legal Capacity, and Imperfect
Legal Capacity. These categories distinguish the level of legal autonomy and
decision-making authority granted to individuals based on their mental and
physical capabilities. Here's a differentiation between these categories:
1. Complete Legal Capacity (Al-Ahl
al-Kamil):
Complete
Legal Capacity refers to individuals who possess full legal capacity and are
considered legally competent and responsible for their actions. They have the
ability to enter into contracts, engage in legal transactions, and exercise all
their legal rights and obligations. They are of sound mind and have reached the
age of maturity (usually defined as reaching puberty or attaining a specific
age, such as 18 years old). Adults who are mentally and physically capable fall
under the category of Complete Legal Capacity.
2. Deficient Legal Capacity (Al-Ahl
al-Naqis):
Deficient
Legal Capacity applies to individuals who have limited legal capacity due to
certain conditions or circumstances. It includes individuals who lack mental
competence or have impaired decision-making abilities. This category
encompasses minors, individuals with mental disabilities, and those who are
mentally impaired due to intoxication or temporary insanity. People with
deficient legal capacity are not considered fully responsible for their actions
and may require guardianship or legal assistance to protect their rights and
interests.
3. Imperfect Legal Capacity (Al-Ahl
al-Mu'akhkhir):
Imperfect
Legal Capacity applies to individuals who have certain limitations or
restrictions on their legal capacity due to specific conditions or
circumstances. This category includes women in matters of marriage and divorce,
where their legal capacity may be subject to additional requirements or
limitations. For example, in some interpretations of Islamic law, a woman may
require the consent of her guardian (wali) for marriage, even though she
possesses complete legal capacity in other aspects of life. The imperfect legal
capacity is not a reflection of intellectual or mental capacity but is specific
to certain legal matters.
It is
important to note that the differentiation of legal capacity in Islamic law
serves to ensure justice, protection, and fairness for individuals based on
their capabilities and specific circumstances. The objective is to safeguard
the rights and interests of individuals while considering their mental,
physical, and social circumstances, ensuring a balanced legal framework that
upholds principles of equity and welfare.
Q.4 Compare
women rights in Judaism and Christianity in detail.
Women's
rights in Judaism and Christianity have evolved over time, influenced by
various interpretations, cultural practices, and historical contexts. While
both religions share common principles of equality and dignity, there are
differences in their approach to women's roles and rights. Here is a detailed
comparison of women's rights in Judaism and Christianity:
1. Scriptural Teachings:
Judaism:
Jewish scriptures, including the Torah and Talmud, emphasize the inherent value
and dignity of both men and women as creations of God. Women are seen as equal
in spiritual worth and are regarded as partners in fulfilling God's covenant.
However, some legal and ritual aspects in traditional Judaism grant men greater
responsibilities and privileges within certain religious practices.
Christianity:
Christian teachings affirm the equal worth and dignity of men and women,
highlighting their shared image of God and value as individuals. Jesus'
ministry challenged cultural norms and treated women with respect and
compassion. The Apostle Paul emphasized the equality of men and women in
Christ, stating that "there is neither male nor female" in terms of
salvation.
Judaism: Within Orthodox
Judaism, women are generally excluded from formal religious leadership roles
such as rabbis and cantors. However, women have historically played significant
roles in Jewish spiritual life as educators, scholars, and leaders in the
domestic sphere. In other branches of Judaism, such as Reform and Conservative,
women have gained more opportunities for religious leadership.
Christianity:
Christian traditions vary in their acceptance of women in leadership roles.
Some denominations ordain women as pastors, priests, and bishops, while others
maintain restrictions based on theological interpretations. In recent decades,
there has been increasing acceptance and promotion of women's leadership in
various Christian contexts.
3. Marriage and Family:
Judaism:
Marriage is highly valued in Judaism, and women have essential roles within the
family unit. Jewish law places certain responsibilities on husbands to provide
for and honor their wives, including financial support and conjugal rights.
Divorce is permitted, but the process can be more complex for women, requiring
the issuance of a religious divorce decree (get).
Christianity:
Christian teachings emphasize the importance of marriage and family,
considering it a sacred bond. Both husbands and wives are called to love,
respect, and serve one another. Divorce is acknowledged but discouraged, with
varying approaches to its permissibility across Christian denominations.
4. Education and Intellectual Pursuits:
Judaism:
Jewish tradition places a strong emphasis on education for both men and women.
Historically, Jewish women have engaged in intellectual pursuits and
contributed to religious scholarship. Modern Jewish educational institutions
generally provide equal educational opportunities for girls and boys.
Christianity:
Christianity has encouraged education for both men and women, with various
Christian schools and universities established to promote intellectual
development. However, throughout history, access to education for women has
been limited in some Christian contexts, though it has improved significantly
in recent times.
5. Social and Legal Rights:
Judaism:
Judaism upholds principles of justice, fairness, and compassion, advocating for
the protection and equal treatment of women. Jewish law contains provisions to
safeguard women's rights, including inheritance rights, financial support, and
protection against mistreatment or abuse.
Christianity:
Christian teachings emphasize the value of justice, compassion, and the
protection of human rights. Christian societies and legal systems have
contributed to the recognition of women's rights, including their right to
vote, access to education, and protection against discrimination and violence.
It is
important to note that interpretations and practices within Judaism and
Christianity can vary among different denominations, cultural contexts, and
historical periods. While progress has been made in promoting gender equality
within both religions, challenges and differing perspectives remain, necessitating
ongoing dialogue and efforts to address gender-based inequalities.
Q.5 Define
Legal Pluralism. Discuss its negative and positive impacts on the lives of men,
women and children in Pakistani context.
Legal
pluralism refers to a situation where multiple legal systems or norms coexist
within a particular society. It recognizes that different communities or groups
may have their own legal traditions, religious laws, customary practices, or
informal dispute resolution mechanisms alongside the state's formal legal
system. In the Pakistani context, legal pluralism is particularly relevant due
to the coexistence of Islamic law (Sharia), British colonial laws, and
customary practices.
Negative
Impacts:
1. Inequality and Discrimination: Legal
pluralism can perpetuate inequality and discrimination, particularly against
marginalized groups, including women and children. Customary or religious laws
may reinforce gender-based discrimination, restricting the rights and freedoms
of women and undermining their equality.
2. Lack of Uniformity and Clarity: The
coexistence of multiple legal systems can lead to confusion, ambiguity, and
inconsistencies in the application and enforcement of laws. This can result in
uncertainty, injustice, and a lack of legal protection for individuals,
especially vulnerable groups like women and children.
3. Limited Access to Justice: Legal
pluralism may create barriers to access justice for marginalized individuals,
particularly women and children. Customary or religious legal systems may be
less accessible, discriminatory, or not adequately equipped to handle cases
involving gender-based violence, property rights, or child protection.
Positive Impacts:
1. Cultural Diversity and Autonomy: Legal
pluralism recognizes and respects diverse cultural practices, traditions, and
religious beliefs within a society. It allows communities to maintain their
unique identity and exercise a degree of autonomy in matters that are important
to them, fostering cultural diversity and pluralism.
2. Dispute Resolution Mechanisms:
Customary or informal dispute resolution mechanisms, operating within legal
pluralism, can provide accessible and affordable means of resolving disputes,
especially in remote or marginalized communities where the formal legal system
may be distant or unfamiliar.
3. Flexibility and Adaptability: Legal
pluralism can provide flexibility and adaptability to evolving societal needs.
Customary or religious laws may have the capacity to evolve and respond to
changing circumstances or local conditions, offering a more contextualized and
localized approach to justice.
iIn the Pakistani context, the impacts of
legal pluralism on the lives of men, women, and children are complex and can
vary depending on factors such as socio-economic status, geographic location,
and religious or cultural background. While legal pluralism can offer some
benefits, such as cultural diversity and accessibility to justice, its negative
impacts, including discrimination and inequality, particularly affect
marginalized groups. Efforts should be made to ensure that legal pluralism is
navigated in a way that upholds human rights, gender equality, and the best
interests of all individuals, irrespective of their gender or age. This may
involve harmonizing customary practices with human rights standards,
strengthening the capacity of informal justice systems to address gender-based
injustices, and promoting legal reforms that ensure equal rights and protection
for all.
Dear Student,
Ye sample assignment h. Ye bilkul
copy paste h jo dusre student k pass b available h. Agr ap ne university
assignment send krni h to UNIQUE assignment
hasil krne k lye ham c contact kren:
0313-6483019
0334-6483019
0343-6244948
University c related har news c
update rehne k lye hamra channel subscribe kren: